bds
|
ba
|
sqft
|
car garage
|
|
Fixer Upper Homes for Sale in Mt Pleasant, Utah
Mt Pleasant sits in the middle of Sanpete Valley about 90 minutes south of Provo, and it has one of the deeper stocks of older homes in central Utah. Main Street is lined with 1880s–1920s brick and stone buildings, and the residential blocks behind it hold pioneer-era homes, Victorian cottages, and early 1900s farmhouses that have been passed down through Sanpete families for generations. That history is exactly why fixer uppers show up here more often than in newer Wasatch Front cities — many of these homes have been lived in by the same family for decades and come to market needing kitchens, baths, mechanical systems, and roofs updated all at once. Prices reflect the work involved, and they remain meaningfully lower than anything comparable in Utah County or Salt Lake.
Buyers chasing project homes in Mt Pleasant tend to fall into a few camps: remote workers wanting acreage and a workshop, retirees looking for a quieter pace near Wasatch Academy and Snow College in Ephraim, and investors targeting short-term rentals tied to the nearby canyons, Skyline Drive, and Palisade State Park. Winters are real here — Mt Pleasant sits at about 5,900 feet and gets serious snow — so insulation, windows, and heating systems should be near the top of any renovation budget. Browse the active listings below to see which homes are currently on the market, and reach out if you want help estimating scope before writing an offer.
April 2026 · Mt Pleasant market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Mt Pleasant right now.
Median sale
$399,000
6 closed in April 2026
Median DOM
30 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
99.3%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
40
active + pending
5 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 5 fixer upper homes on a map
Pan around Mt Pleasant and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About fixer upper homes in Mt Pleasant.
What kind of fixer uppers typically come up in Mt Pleasant? ▾
The most common projects are turn-of-the-century brick pioneer homes along State Street and the side streets near Main, plus mid-century ranches and the occasional farmhouse on an acre or two at the edges of town. Many of the older homes have good bones — full-dimension lumber, brick exteriors, mature trees — but need updated wiring, plumbing, windows, and kitchens. Outbuildings, sheds, and detached garages on these properties often need work too.
Can I get a renovation loan on a Mt Pleasant fixer upper? ▾
Yes. FHA 203(k) and Fannie Mae HomeStyle loans both work in Sanpete County and roll purchase price plus renovation costs into one mortgage. USDA renovation loans are also an option here since most of Mt Pleasant qualifies as rural. Your lender will want contractor bids and a scope of work before closing, so line that up early.
Are there historic district rules I need to know about? ▾
Mt Pleasant has a recognized historic Main Street and several homes on the National Register, but the city does not currently enforce strict design review on most private renovations. That said, if you're touching a registered property or pursuing historic tax credits through the Utah State Historic Preservation Office, exterior changes need to follow the Secretary of the Interior's Standards. Check with the city before replacing windows or altering the facade on any pre-1940 home.
What should I budget for a full renovation in Sanpete County? ▾
Contractors out of Ephraim, Manti, and Spanish Fork are the usual labor pool, and rates run lower than Utah County but availability is tight. Plan on roughly $90–$160 per square foot for a full interior remodel, more if you're redoing foundation, roof, and mechanicals on a 1900s home. Getting two or three bids is worth the wait — pricing varies a lot between crews here.
Is well and septic common on these properties? ▾
Inside Mt Pleasant city limits most homes are on city water and sewer, which simplifies a remodel. Properties on the outskirts toward Indianola, Fairview, or up Pleasant Creek Canyon are more likely to have a well and septic system, both of which should be inspected before you write an offer. Septic replacement alone can run $8,000–$20,000 depending on soils and drainfield size.
How's resale on a renovated home in Mt Pleasant? ▾
Mt Pleasant has been picking up buyers priced out of Utah County and remote workers wanting acreage, so a well-done renovation on a character home tends to sell. Just be realistic about ceiling prices — comparable finished homes in town generally trade well below Wasatch Front numbers, so over-improving a property is the main risk. Match your finish level to what recent sales support.