Catalina Bay Homes For Sale

Catalina Bay is a new-construction community in Saratoga Springs built almost entirely after 2020, with homes averaging 4,432 square feet on roughly quarter-acre lots and a modest HOA fee of $55 per month. Transaction volume is very limited — only 7 listings recorded over the past year — so the price data carries a wide range: the one sale logged in June 2025 closed at $1,120,000 after 89 days on market at a 103.7% sale-to-list ratio, while the one sale in May 2026 moved at $734,000 in 25 days at 97.9% of list price. Current list prices on active inventory span from $750,000 to $1,250,000, reflecting meaningful variation in floor plans and finish levels within this small subdivision. All homes feed Westlake High and predominantly Lake Mountain Middle, while the elementary assignment splits between Harbor Point Elementary (46%) and Sage Hills Elementary.