bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
Horse Properties for Sale in Monticello, Utah
Monticello sits at just over 7,000 feet on the eastern slope of the Abajo Mountains, and it's one of the few towns in Utah where you can own real acreage, run a few head of horses, and ride straight into national forest without trailering. San Juan County zoning is friendly to livestock, parcels of 5 to 40 acres are common, and the surrounding mix of Manti-La Sal National Forest and BLM ground gives owners hundreds of square miles of legal riding country — from the cool aspen and pine of the Blue Mountains down into the slickrock toward Canyonlands and Indian Creek. Hay grows well in the valley with irrigation, summer temperatures stay in the low 80s, and winter snow is real but manageable with a decent shelter and a tank heater.
Buyers shopping equestrian acreage here tend to fall into two camps: working ranchers expanding a cow-calf or outfitting operation, and out-of-state owners trading Front Range or California prices for room to breathe. Either way, the practical questions are the same — water rights, well depth, fencing condition, outbuilding quality, and winter access on county roads. Listings in this market move slower than along the Wasatch Front, so there's usually time to do proper due diligence on water shares, septic, and pasture carrying capacity. Browse the active horse properties below to see what's currently on the market in Monticello and the surrounding San Juan County communities.
June 2026 · Monticello market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Monticello right now.
Median sale
$286,250
1 closed in June 2026
Median DOM
12 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
103.0%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
17
active + pending
17 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 17 horse properties on a map
Pan around Monticello and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About horse properties in Monticello.
How much acreage do horse properties in Monticello typically include? ▾
Most equestrian parcels in and around Monticello run from 2 to 40 acres, with quite a few larger spreads on the outskirts toward Verdure, Devil's Canyon, and the Abajo (Blue) Mountains foothills. Smaller in-town lots near the 7,000-foot bench often have room for two or three horses, while ranches south toward Eastland or west toward the national forest support full herds.
What's the climate like for keeping horses year-round in Monticello? ▾
Monticello sits at roughly 7,070 feet, so winters are real — expect snow from November into March and overnight lows in the teens. Plan on a heated water source, a windbreak or three-sided shelter at minimum, and stored hay for 5-6 months. Summers are mild (highs in the low 80s), which makes riding season long and comfortable compared to St. George or the Wasatch Front.
Is water rights a concern on San Juan County horse properties? ▾
Yes — water is the first thing to check on any acreage purchase here. Some properties pull from the Monticello culinary system, others rely on wells, and irrigation rights tied to Loyd's Lake or local ditches add real value. Ask for a water rights deed or share certificate before going under contract, and verify the well log with the Utah Division of Water Rights.
What riding access do owners get from Monticello? ▾
The Manti-La Sal National Forest sits right above town, with trailheads up Harts Draw and around the Abajo Peaks giving direct backcountry access. South and east of town, BLM ground stretches for miles toward Canyonlands and Hovenweep. Many owners trailer 20 minutes and ride all day without crossing pavement.
How do horse property prices in Monticello compare to other Utah markets? ▾
San Juan County is one of the more affordable equestrian markets in the state. Acreage with a modest home and outbuildings often lists well below comparable setups in Heber, Morgan, or Cache Valley. Larger working ranches with water rights carry a premium, but the per-acre cost is still a fraction of what you'd pay along the Wasatch Back.
Are there zoning or HOA restrictions on keeping horses? ▾
Outside the Monticello city limits, San Juan County zoning is generally permissive — A-1 and RR designations allow horses with minimal restrictions on animal counts per acre. Inside city limits, check the specific zone and any subdivision CC&Rs. HOAs are rare out here compared to Front-range Utah, which is part of the appeal for buyers who want to run their place without a board's input.