Brookside Homes For Sale

Brookside is a residential subdivision in Payson built predominantly between 2000 and 2009, with homes averaging around 2,084 square feet on roughly 0.14-acre lots and a modest HOA fee of $17 per month. Over the past year, 15 homes were listed — a relatively limited sample — with median sale prices ranging from $335,000 to $595,000 across individual months; the most active stretch came in September 2025, when 4 homes closed at a median of $430,000 with days on market at 24. Days on market have varied notably, from as few as 7 days to as many as 93, reflecting uneven pace rather than a steady trend. Nearly all homes here feed into Payson High (98% share) and Spring Lake Elementary (79% share), while the middle school splits between Payson Jr Middle and Mt. Nebo Middle.